The prospect of cloning humans is highly controversial and raises a number of ethical, legal and social challenges that need to be considered. Cloning conversations must address the implications on the future and how manmade selection through cloning will effect the development of the human species as well as the world. With this invention, the world made a aggregate astonishment at the realization that cloning was no longer an aspect of a science fiction movie. The assembly of patientspecific cardiomyocytes, blood vessels and skin pieces fixed on a scaffold 39 holds great. It dispenses with the need to inject a gene into thousands of newly fertilized eggs to get a successful result. Arguments supporting research cloning the main use of research cloning is to create human embryonic stem cells hesc. Yet, cloning human beings will cause identity issues, social issues, and possibly financial issues for both the clone and the one being cloned. In each of her monthly cycles, a woman usually produces only. A few days ago, brigitte boisselier a leader of a religious sect called the raelians announced that the worlds first cloned baby has been born. It dispenses with the need to inject a gene into thousands of newly. Whether this justification of human research cloning is legitimate is analyzed in the upcoming section of the chapter on ethical issues. The safety of the process hundreds of cells fail to develop succesfully. But federal funding is only a small piece of a much larger set of moral and political issues. I have based much of my information used in this short article regarding cloning and its ethical dimensions on the the.
In 2005, the united nations attempted to pass a global ban on human cloning, but was unsuccessful due to disagreements over whether therapeutic cloning should be included. The need to obtain a supply of human eggs leads to one of the most sensitive ethical issues cloning research. Bioethical issues educational fact sheets train your pupils in a participatory approach, fundamental to education for citizenship, by organising an informed, multidisciplinary debate. The issue of human reproductive cloning has recently received a great deal attention in public discourse. There are some ethical issues about the livestock and plants also.
Why the legal and ethical issues surrounding cloning will be. Biotechnology, ethics, and the politics of cloning1. The ethical implications of human cloning harvard university. This aspect does not only have legal implications, but also appeals to the moral conscience of the individual. Ethical aspects of cloning techniques european commission. Ian wilmut had succeeded in cloning a sheep, people around the world have been participating in a frenzied debate over the morality of. I am also assuming that you are referring to human reproductive cloning. Ethical issues of cloning 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ethical issues. The cloning of a monkey or other nonhuman primate would likely be a strong signal that its time to set some rules around human cloning, cibelli said.
The ethics of cloning early in 1997, scottish scientist dr. Reproductive cloning is moral 14 panayiotis zavos 3. What are the solutions to the ethical problems posed by human. Conversely, blanket legislation prohibiting all forms of cloning would disallow valuable research and clinical methods in the cloning of dna strands or cells in culture. In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human cloning. Ill try and examine each possible ethical concern that i can think of since you havent listed any, ill assume you mean any across the spectrum. Other cloning projects seek to create diseaseresistant animals, which could lead to healthier animal lives and greater animal welfare. Otherwise there is no use of cloning of any animal if it is not of any use. Cloning and the international communityw hile the cloning issue seemed to project endlessly into the future, the task of setting and implementing an. Religious perspectives two religion panelists, suzanne holland and laurie zoloth, are co editors of the human embryonic stem cell debate. Whether it be to actually clone a human to raise as a child, or for medical purposes, i do not think that cloning should be allowed to take place.
The ethical debate on cloning in the article, biotechnology, ethics and the politics of cloning, the authors, steven best and douglas kellner describe the advantages and disadvantages of. This teaching aid, developed by the council of europe, is designed in particular for fourth form to upper sixth form teachers. Therapeutic cloning can save lives 30 raymond barglow 5. Applications of gene cloning in medicine, both pdf for diagnosis and treatment, and in the pharmaceutical industry and agriculture, are also covered in the book. While many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well. A fundamental argument is that cloning is ethically wrong and various religious groups have rejected it saying that cloning is equivalent to playing god. Indeed, the commission itself is unable to agree at this time on all the ethical issues that surround the issue of cloning human beings in this manner. Ian wilmot revealed to the world that he had successfully cloned an adult sheep, dolly. It involves the process of somatic cell nuclear transfer in which the nucleus of a cell from a human patients body is injected into a human ovum which has had its nucleus removed. They give various examples and judge them from different perspectives. Bioethical issues educational fact sheets train your pupils in a participatory approach, fundamental to education for citizenship, by organising an informed, multidisciplinary debate on bioethical issues.
The ethical issues of cloning 1785 words 123 help me. The ethical issues with reproductive cloning include genetic damage to the clone, health risks to the mother, very low success rate meaning loss of large numbers of embryos and fetuses. Arguments supporting research cloning the main use of research cloning is to create human. Sep 22, 2015 other animals raises ethical issues, this article focuses on human beings.
A fundamental argument is that cloning is ethically wrong and various religious groups have. The process of being natural is all that matters, so that no body will be blamed of the outcome. The developmental events between the fertilized zygote and the mature organism specialisation of cells to fulfill specific functions, i. Gene cloning takes a fresh approach to teaching molecular and cellular biology and will be a valuable resource to both undergraduates and lecturers of biological and biomedical science. Cloning is a dominant topic under the broader category of biotechnology. Ethical implications of cloning techniques, namely animal cloning and applications potential to human beings. These animals should give benefit to the producers. Rather, much as the printing press replaced the scribe, cloning allows mass reproduction of a devised type, and. Aug 05, 2012 cloning and the international communityw hile the cloning issue seemed to project endlessly into the future, the task of setting and implementing an international ethical and legal framework for human cloning was all themore pressing by the cascade of laboratory developments at the end of the 20th century. Human cloning is the creation of a genetically identical copy of a human. I will here mainly discuss the apparent ethical concerns related to human reproductive cloning. Indeed, the commission itself is unable to agree at this time on all the ethical issues that surround the issue of cloning human beings in.
Pdf ethical aspects within human cloning researchgate. Essay on what are the ethical issues of human cloning cram. In the cloning process, the dna is removed from cells, manipulations of the dna are carried out in a testtube, and the dna is subsequently put back into cells. In some cases, cloning human beings is good for pure genetic purposes and possibly furthering humanity into new scientific spaces. The use of cloning and stem cells to resurrect life. The ethical implications of human cloning spring 2005 volume 48, number 2 243 it might be replied that cloning and genetic engineering are in principle no different from other ways in which parents go to great lengths to produce children of a certain kind, or designer children. All three panelists commended the decision of the state advisory committee to deal separately with the issues of human cloning and stem cell research. Dna cloning cloning is the process of moving a gene from the chromosome it occurs in naturally to an autonomously replicating vector. However, this means that cloning by nuclear transfer into an empty egg cell is not prohibited, leaving open a loophole for dollylike cloning. Cloning is rapidly emerging as one of the most controversial and emotionladen of topics in todays world. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research markkula. Feb 22, 2017 i will here mainly discuss the apparent ethical concerns related to human reproductive cloning. Ethical issues in animal cloning scholarlycommons university of. Ever since the advent of cloning, there have been arguments for and against this process.
Cloning is a return to asexual reproduction and bypasses the caprice of the genetic lottery and random shuffling of genes. Dec 31, 2002 a few days ago, brigitte boisselier a leader of a religious sect called the raelians announced that the worlds first cloned baby has been born. Moral and ethical issues of human cloning philosophy essay. Does an embryo, at whatever stage of its existence, have the same right as human beings. The ethical issues in animal cloning given the diverse motivations and types of animal cloning, the ethical terrain is complex. This timely anthology offers a range of expert opinion, from scientific, religious. In each of her monthly cycles, a woman usually produces only one or two mature eggs. A clone is an organism that has generally identical genetic composition to another organism.
In other words, if the research will benefit people, we should do it. Moral, ethical, and regulatory issues dolly, woolly, innocent, and sweet, strongly contrasts with the severity of the issues that she has raised. While there is no perfected cloning technique to date, considerations of the morality of cloning should address cloning in context to the present as well as projected. Therapeutic cloning is immoral 37 william saunders 6. Here is a discussion about the ethical issues that have arisen concerned with cloning humans. In the cloning process, the dna is removed from cells. Human cloning could potentially lead to genetic altering of children to be what people could call a pure race. For example, if an animal is cloned, it should be kept in mind that health of the animal should not be affected. Chapter 6 the ethics of cloning for reproductive purposes. The ethical implications of human cloning spring 2005 volume 48, number 2 243 it might be replied that cloning and genetic engineering are in principle no different from other ways in. For now, human cloning remains in a stalemate from both a scientific and public policy perspective the future of human cloning will likely depend on which side gives in first. The ethical issues with reproductive cloning include genetic damage to the clone, health risks to the mother, very low success rate meaning loss of large numbers of embryos and fetuses, psychological harm to the clone, complex altered familial relationships, and commodification of human life. The ethical debate on cloning in the article, biotechnology, ethics and the politics of cloning, the authors, steven best and douglas kellner describe the advantages and disadvantages of cloning and discuss the ethical issues related to cloning.
For example, if an animal is cloned, it should be kept in mind that health of the animal. It seems clear to all of us, however, given the current stage of science in this area, that. The legal and ethical issues of cloning that make it. The ethical issues involved are both numerous and controversial. Therapeutic cloning is also called biomedical cloning, and research cloning. In summary,animal cloning raises two types of moral problems. On a smaller scale i do not see the need for cloning to take place. There is great public concern with the ethics of human cloning.
1452 1461 680 1045 793 628 918 690 615 698 614 1412 867 1343 1372 1284 676 348 193 710 329 1026 1118 1316 740 130 260 691 1007 576 286 810 358 888 558 685 1383 876 746 513 307 650 800 330